Wife and I came here to celebrate an anniversary. We had reservations and they wished us a happy anniversary upon arrival and after seating. Beyond that, they did nothing else to make the evening special. The food was okay, but not for the price point. They seem to be striving for a certain aesthetic but are not doing enough to warrant it. We had much better eating for better pricing over the course of our three day stay on the island. The service was very good.
Me and my friends (6) visited the place for lunch. 3 of my friends came to the place with sandals. The way we were greeted by the management was worst. The way he looked at my friends feet and the way he commented " I can't allow you into the place with those feet"; made us irritated and frustrated. I guess your management should work on their hospitality skills. If there is a dress code to enter your restaurant mention it on your front door!
There are so many other places to eat it's hard to say this place is any more than just Ok. There were 4 families here when we came, while we were there another couple came and was seated behind us. Their table wasn't clean. It was 5:30pm. Seems rather inexcusable considering how early it was and how empty this place was. The food we ordered, was adequate but sat heavily like a rock. We didn't order anything fancy and ate off the light menu. But I don't think we'll be returning. One bright spot was our waitress Sandy. She was friendly, helpful, and you could tell she was proud of being good at her job.
Goodfellows Grill:
Drinks were good. Service initially was fine, but everything went downhill after appetizers. Food was brought out and half of the order was incorrect (party of 8). The dishes that were brought out were lukewarm at best. The chicken alfredo came with ONE small piece of chicken. See the attached picture of the "Jamaican" chicken sandwich that came with only 5 (yes 5) fries. Finally, the other half of the food arrived and there was not a single apology from the waitress. Also, she seemingly disappeared until she brought our check, never asking us if everything was alright (clearly it wasn't). Spend your money elsewhere.
Great atmosphere sitting on the porch overlooking the main street. Great flatbread pizza and burgers. Wait staff was friendly and efficient.
Long short of it, we will likely not be returning until we see some recent reviews that convince us otherwise.
Goodfellows Restaurant is a US Restaurant based in Mackinac Island, Michigan. Goodfellows Restaurant is located at 1359 Hoban St, Mackinac Island, MI 49757, USA.
Please contact with Goodfellows Restaurant using information above: Address, Phone number, Fax, Postal code, Website address, E-mail, Facebook. Find Goodfellows Restaurant opening hours and driving directions or map. Find real customer reviews and ratings or write your own review.
Find Restaurant in Mackinac Island